Why the scale isn’t the best measure of fitness
For many, the scale is the go-to measure of progress in fitness. Step on it every day (or week), and the number you see is often seen as the ultimate indicator of how well you’re doing. However, relying solely on the scale can be misleading and even discouraging. Especially if you’re working on improving your body composition and overall health.
1. Muscle vs. Fat: One of the biggest reasons the scale isn’t always an accurate indicator of fitness is that it doesn’t differentiate between muscle mass and fat. As you engage in strength training or resistance exercises, you may gain muscle while losing fat. Muscle weighs more than fat, so you might not see a significant drop in weight even though your body composition is improving. You might even gain a few pounds of lean muscle while reducing body fat.
2. Health Comes in Many Forms: Fitness is more than just weight. It’s about strength, endurance, flexibility, and overall well-being. Someone who is building endurance or improving their flexibility may not see dramatic changes on the scale, but these improvements are important markers of physical health. It’s crucial to focus on how you feel, your energy levels, and your ability to perform physical tasks rather than just a number.
3. Weight Fluctuations Are Normal: Weight naturally fluctuates due to various factors such as water retention, hormone levels, and dietary changes. These temporary changes can make the scale less reliable for tracking true fitness progress. On any given day, your weight could vary by a few pounds for reasons that have nothing to do with fat loss or muscle gain.
Focus on Non-Scale Victories
Instead of obsessing over the scale, consider other markers of progress, such as fitting into clothes better, achieving personal fitness goals (like running a mile faster or lifting heavier weights), or noticing improvements in mental health. These “non-scale victories” often reflect long-term, sustainable health improvements.
If your journey ONLY requires “weight-loss” and this is your main goal then it would be beneficial to use the scale for this method as your indicator. Yes, weighing yourself every day or every week is key. But remember, weight will go up a couple pounds and drop a couple pounds daily…
If your mindset is not prepared for this, it can be frustrating. What we want is a trend over time downward. If this is not the trend, adjustments should be made.
While the scale can offer some insights into weight loss, it doesn’t paint the full picture of fitness success. It’s important to take a holistic approach and consider factors like body composition, strength.. By doing so, you’ll have a much clearer sense of your fitness progress and well-being.
Command Coaching
